When son Blair Prewett refused to shift from an Auckland apartment owned by a family trust, trustees secured a loan over the property with Blair forced out following a later mortgagee sale. His claim to hold a life tenancy over the apartment was dismissed; he had no more than a licence to reside at the property, which could be cancelled.
The High Court was told that the apartment in Kingsland was held by a family trust, with both his parents as initial trustees.
Blair came to live with his parents around 2012 after debilitating surgery and ongoing treatment for brain cancer.
He was to later claim his parents agreed that in return for him staying in the apartment and assisting in their care he would have a life tenancy, giving him the right to live in the apartment rent free and outgoings free until his death.
His father died in 2022.
Later that year, his mother shifted against his wishes to a retirement village, diagnosed with dementia.
Against this background, the initial family trust was re-settled with new trustees appointed.
Evidence was given of Blair refusing to engage with the new trustees, who were looking to sell the apartment to pay his mother’s retirement home fees, already $55,000 in arrears.
He was told repeatedly that the Kingsland apartment was a trust asset and there was no formal arrangement or trustee consent allowing him to remain.
Trustees mortgaged the apartment, generating $125,000 to finance his mother’s ongoing accommodation costs.
With this loan unpaid, Blair was forced out following a mortgagee sale.
He sued the new trustees, alleging a failure to recognise his claimed life tenancy.
To trustees’ surprise, he produced in court a 2014 agreement signed by himself and his parents granting a life tenancy.
The court was told he made no mention of this document in his earlier dispute over rights to remain in the apartment.
Associate Judge Lester ruled the new trustees were not bound by this 2014 agreement. They were unaware of its existence when the trust was resettled; they were under no obligation to search out what promises might have been made by his parents.
Separately, Blair claimed rights to the Kingsland apartment as tenant under the Residential Tenancies Act, with the effect that a mortgagee sale did not affect his rights as a tenant – in this case his right to remain a tenant for life.
Judge Lester stated the Act excludes family living arrangements from the Act’s definition of residential tenancies.
Blair had no more than a licence to occupy, he ruled. This licence expired in October 2022 when the original trust was re-settled and new trustees appointed, replacing the previous trustees who had allowed Blair to live rent free in the apartment.
Prewett v. Professional Trustee Services 2023 Ltd – High Court (4.09.26)
26.253