04 September 2026

Co-ownership: Roberts v. Mauga

  

Left stranded as part-owner of a Bay of Plenty property with no ability to remove a tenant enjoying two decades of below market rent, or even being able to sell, because fellow co-owners refused to engage, caused the High Court to order a forced sale with net proceeds divided fifty/fifty.

Moewai Roberts became owner of a half share in the 92 hectare rural property in 2008 after her husband’s death.  Owner of the other half share died the following year, with ownership of that half share held since 2009 by Maramoa Mauga and Michael Wilson as estate executors.

The High Court was told these two executors have ignored existence of this estate asset.

The property at Waimana, inland between Whakatane and Opotiki, was leased prior to Ms Robert’s inheritance to a company called L.A. Brown & Sons Ltd, described on the Companies Office register as a dairy and cattle farm.

Evidence was given of Brown & Sons original lease expiring in 2007 with the company continuing in occupation over the next twenty years without a renewed lease, paying the original rental of some $7000 per year.

Current market rentals for a property of this size vary between $36,000 and $48,000, the court was told.

Rentals have been paid to Ms Roberts.  The amount now barely covers likely outgoings for rates and insurance.

Ms Roberts said she has been unable to renegotiate the rent because the co-owners will not co-operate; necessary to sign off on a new lease.  The two estate executors are believed to be living in Australia.

Now in her eighties, Ms Roberts wants to sell.  The property has a current market value of between $1.7 million and $1.9 million.

Justice Harvey ordered a Property Law Act sale, with Ms Roberts alone authorised to end Brown & Sons occupation and to negotiate a sale price with intending purchasers.

Fifty per cent of net proceeds is to be held in trust for beneficiaries of the inactive estate.

Separately, Ms Roberts asked that damages be deducted from the estate’s other half share as compensation for lost rent; her half share of lost rent likely to exceed $100,000.

The executors’ lack of engagement as co-owners has prevented any rent increase for over two decades, she complained.

A separate hearing is needed to determine liability for rent, Justice Harvey ruled.

Executors have the right to challenge this separate claim.

Substituted notice of the earlier Property Law Act sale application was served on the two executors by email.

They did not respond.

Roberts v. Mauga – High Court (4.09.26)

26.251

02 September 2026

Debt: SS Impex Ltd v. Tru Value

  

High Court dismissed as utterly implausible an Auckland retail grocer’s claim that his India supplier negligently slipped 45 kilograms of tobacco into a dry goods shipment without his knowledge, after which Satish Kumar Singh then took no immediate action, waiting for years until later using this tobacco infiltration as a reason for not paying debts owed his India supplier for dry goods subsequently supplied.

The tobacco was seized by Customs in 2024.

The High Court was told Singh’s company SS Impex Ltd sat silent on its supposed tobacco complaint for two years before claiming a set-off against the cost of dry goods subsequently imported when threatened with liquidation for non-payment of these later debts.

Mr Singh told the High Court SS Impex faced a $407,000 fine for the undeclared importation of tobacco; all the fault of its India supplier, he alleged.

Evidence put before the court as evidence of this fine was disputed.

Associate Judge Lester ruled there was a mismatch between the seizure notice and the supposed fine, both as to timing and documentation.

The $407,000 supposed fine referenced customs duty payable, with no mention of tobacco product.  Mr Singh could not explain why a supposed fine included $88,900 in ‘compensatory interest.’

SS Impex was not convicted of any Customs and Excise Act offence; a precursor to any fine.   

There was no link between the claimed innocent importation of tobacco and the supposed fine sufficient to justify a reduction in debts owed, Judge Lester ruled.

SS Impex was ordered to pay within two weeks debts totalling US$131,600 claimed by its India supplier, or face liquidation.

SS Impex Ltd v. Tru Value Overseas Pty Ltd – High Court (2.09.26)

26.249

01 September 2026

Relationship Property: Sharma v. Sikka

  

Cash contributions made by Devender Sharma’s mother living with her son and his spouse Rubina Sikka during their brief marriage did not count when assessing relationship property contributions after the marriage ended.

The assumed 50/50 split of relationship assets at the end of a marriage does not apply to marriages of short duration.  Instead, each party’s share is determined by their individual contributions, both financial and non-financial, with no presumption that monetary contributions are of greater value than non-monetary contributions.

Mr Sharma challenged a Family Court Property (Relationships) Act ruling dividing net assets equally at end of his nearly two year relationship with Ms Sikka.

He said cash provided by his mother should be included as a contribution by him, with the couples’ net assets to be divided 65/35 in his favour.

The Property (Relationships) Act measures financial and non-financial contributions made by spouses in marriages of short duration, not contributions made by parents, Justice Blanchard ruled.

The court was told Mr Sharma’s mother paid across $60,400: a $27,000 contribution towards purchase of a family home registered in her son’s name and $33,400 used to pay for ‘household chattels and home expenditure.’

Confirming the Family Court ruling that a 50/50 split of relationship assets was appropriate in this case, Justice Blanchard said Mr Sharma’s mother’s payment of $60,400 during her son’s nearly two year marriage equated to payment of some $351 per week and was to be treated as contributions to her own living costs.

It was not a contribution towards relationship assets.

Separately, Mr Sharma claimed the $60,400 received from his mother was a loan, to be deducted from relationship property before any 50/50 split.

There is no documentary evidence of a loan being made, Justice Blanchard said.

Ms Sikka denied there had ever been a loan.

Value of the couple’s net relationship assets to be split 50/50 totalled $80,200: primarily equity in the family home and the value of Mr Sharma’s Range Rover.

Mr Sharma retains ownership of the home and vehicle; paying $40,100 to his former spouse.

Sharma v. Sikka – High Court (1.09.26)

26.250

31 August 2026

Loan: Piacun v. Witham

  

High Court ordered Auckland builder Maurice Witham repay immediately an overdue $430,000 loan from acquaintance Tony Piacun, arranged at a time when Mr Whitham’s business was facing strong financial headwinds and he was supposedly acting in Mr Piacun’s best interests holding an enduring power of attorney on Mr Piacun’s behalf.

Put to one side for a later full hearing in the High Court were Mr Witham’s claims that he is owed money for work done on two properties owned by Mr Piacun and that a dispute about interest on the $430,000 loan has not been finalised.

There is no argument that the $430,000 loan is overdue and unpaid, Justice O’Gorman said.  It is to be repaid immediately, she ruled.

The court was told of the two being acquainted since 2009; Mr Witham’s children mowed lawns for Mr Piacun’s late mother.

Mr Witham says he provided financial assistance to Mr Piacun after his mother’s death; paying for her funeral and paying rates arrears.  

Mr Witham says he then provided further assistance intended to improve Mr Piacun’s financial position; renovating a property Mr Piacun owns in Thames and renovating an Auckland property in Sandringham inherited from his mother, with work starting in late 2020.

In 2021, Mr Piacun signed a power of attorney in favour of Mr Witham and his spouse.

Within a few months, this power of attorney was used to access Mr Piacun’s bank account.

Mr Piacun alleges $939,000 was wrongly drawn down from his account, with $678,000 outstanding after some repayments made by the Whithams.

They say these drawdowns were done either with Mr Piacun’s permission or were reimbursement for renovation work completed on his behalf.

Mr Piacun revoked their power of attorney, appointing his daughter instead.

Included in the disputed $678,000 is an October 2022 loan of $425,000 signed by Mr Piacun between himself and a company owned by the Withams called Hibiscus Views Trust Ltd.  The Whithams personally guaranteed Hibiscus Views December 2025 repayment.

While the loan was stated to be for $425,000 bank records show $430,000 was in fact drawn down from Mr Piacun’s bank account.

Mr Piacun’s daughter later initiated legal action, alleging withdrawals from her father’s bank account have been made without his authority and in breach of fiduciary duties the Withams owed him through the power of attorney they then held.

While ordering the overdue $430,000 be repaid immediately, Justice O’Gorman said a full court hearing is needed to determine any credit for the Withams against the balance claimed.

The Withams say it was agreed that they would contribute towards Mr Piacun’s living expenses in lieu of interest on the loan.

Their claim to a credit for renovations done for Mr Piacun’s benefit is complicated by the fact that this work was not invoiced by Mr Witham personally, instead invoiced by a company controlled by Mr Witham called Orewa Solutions Ltd. 

Orewa Solutions went into liquidation insolvent in January 2025.

Piacun v. Witham – High Court (31.08.26)

26.245

Reckless Trading: Callin Auto v. Fujisawa

  

Ordered to pay $1.01 million for reckless trading as the New Zealand-based director of a Japan used car exporter, Yujiro Fujisawa had the High Court re-open the case on grounds his poor understanding of English and unfamiliarity with the New Zealand legal process meant he missed his day in court.

In May 2025, Callin Auto New Zealand Ltd liquidators got judgment by default against Mr Fujisawa for Companies Act reckless trading on evidence that the company had been trading at a loss for some ten years.

Callin Auto was set up in 2012 to sell used cars in New Zealand, imported from Japan.

Mr Fujiswa claims he is being held liable for New Zealand trading losses as a scapegoat by Callin Auto’s owners in Japan.

They were aware of their New Zealand company’s parlous financial position, but pressed him to continue business, he claims. 

High Court rules allow a default judgment to be set aside or varied where there may have been a miscarriage of justice.

Mr Fujisawa told the court he did not ignore legal action taken against him.

He did consult lawyers, but progress fizzled out when he could not pay their legal fees.

He went to the High Court registry, producing documents and speaking to staff for advice on what he should do.

Mr Fujisawa claims he did not get notice of the High Court hearing where he was subsequently ordered to pay $1.01 million damages.

On getting advice of the adverse court ruling he again contacted court staff, and then a law firm.

He acted for himself in court when asking the case be reopened.

Justice Blanchard ruled reopening was appropriate.

Mr Fujisawa must accept some responsibility for trading losses, he said.

It is a case of what level of damages he should pay.

Judges have a discretion in deciding the level of damages for any breach of directors’ duties.  

Of Callin Auto’s $1.01 million unpaid debts, $978,000 is owed Japan.

Mr Fujisawa considers Japan should bear this loss.

A further court hearing is required.

Callin Auto New Zealand Ltd v. Fujisawa – High Court (31.08.26)

26.248

Asset Forfeiture: Commssioner of Police v. Nicol

  

Alleging that Max Nicol made more than $513,000 dealing in cannabis from his Whangarei address, Police settled for payment of $100,000 in full settlement of a proceeds of crime application taking the pragmatic view Nicol had no further assets capable of being seized.

Nicol was sentenced in 2025 to eleven months home detention following conviction on counts of dealing in cannabis.

A 2024 Police bust found digital scales and ziplock bags of cannabis stored at his home.

Analysis of phone records and bank account deposits were consistent with several years dealing in cannabis, acting as a middleman sourcing cannabis from growers for supply to customers.

Using powers under the Criminal Proceeds (Recovery) Act, Police seized his Toyota Hilux and Ford Ranger.  A restraining order was placed on Nicol’s Westpac Kiwisaver account.

Collectively, value of these assets came to just under $120,000.

In the High Court, Justice Wilkinson-Smith approved an out of court settlement seeing a total of $100,000 forfeited.

The prospect of obtaining a forfeiture order against Nicol for the full $513,000 financial benefit received is remote, she said.

Police agreed $20,000 be returned to Nicol.

Seeking forfeiture of the full $120,000 would cause Nicol’s spouse to make a hardship claim to a share of the funds, Police said.

Commissioner of Police v. Nicol – High Court (31.08.26)

26.246

Executor: re Estate Frances Jean Floyd

  

Delaying distribution of their late mother’s estate as leverage in a dispute over her household chattels led to Ray Floyd’s removal as estate executor and a court order that he contribute to legal costs forcing his removal.

His mother Frances Floyd was aged one hundred at time of her death at Whakatane in 2022.

In her will, she asked all her estate be divided equally between her five children, with one proviso; daughter Ayleen, who had lived with her, was given a life interest in the family home on King Street.

Ayleen died six months after her mother.

Appointed joint executor with his brother Richard, Ray held up distribution of estate assets totalling some $570,000 for nearly four years while he disputed both the value and distribution of estate chattels.  

His main gripe was that their mother had insured her household effects for $115,000.  This amount should be available for distribution, Ray claimed.

Insured value is no evidence of market value, Justice MacGillivray pointed out.

Ray was critical of Ayleen having taken furniture with her when shifting out of King Street in her final months, of her taking possession of their mother’s car (eventually sold for scrap at $250), of the manner in which other furniture was sold through a local auction house (recovering $872), of small household items given away to a charity shop, and a neighbour being gifted an old washing machine.

Disposal of their mother’s personal effects was managed by family before probate was granted and executors appointed; technically illegal, but unexceptional for low value chattels in a parent’s estate, Justice MacGillivray commented.

There is no evidence that anything of material value was given away or sold at an undervalue, he said.

The court was told Ray’s siblings had no objection to the manner in which their late mother’s chattels and personal effects were disposed of.

Ray claimed sister Ayleen had misspent their mother’s money whilst living with her.

Justice MacGillivray said Ray provided no evidence of wrongdoing.  That their mother met some of Ayleen’s expenses while they lived together and Ayleen cared for her is not evidence of wrongdoing, he said.

Ray acted unreasonably in delaying distribution, he ruled.

His brother Richard remains as sole executor following Ray’s removal.

re Estate of Frances Jean Floyd – High Court (31.08.26)

26.247

28 August 2026

Nuisance: Larsen v. Runes Investments

  

Each neighbour blamed the other for landslip damage on Fenton Street in Thames, with the High Court ruling upside neighbour Christine Larsen liable in the tort of nuisance for failing to properly stabilise her driveway.  She was ordered to install a proper retaining wall and pay $350,000 damages to neighbouring property owner, an Australian-registered company: Runes Investments Pty Ltd. 

Property owners are liable in nuisance for the foreseeable consequences of any ongoing activity causing substantial interference with a neighbour’s use of their land.

Runes Investment complained ongoing water run-off from Ms Larsen’s driveway led to a landslip on Runes Investments’ property in the aftermath of cyclone Gabrielle in 2023 and was an ongoing threat to other properties further downhill.

Runes Investments purchased 303A Fenton Street in 2013; Ms Larsen, neighbouring 303B the following year.

Ms Larsen claimed the landslip was caused by Runes Investments excavations for its driveway at 303A.

Evidence was given of Ms Larsen’s neighbouring concrete driveway at 303B being constructed by a previous owner on top of fill, raising the level of this driveway above the then natural contour of the land.

Prior to the 2023 cyclone Gabrielle landslip, Runes Investments got specialist engineering and geo-technical reports on five occasions on how to best remediate intermittent flooding and minor slips emanating from Ms Larsen’s 303B.

Construction of a properly drained retaining wall on Ms Larsen’s property was recommended.

She was provided with copies of these reports.

The court was told she obtained no specialist reports of her own and chose to ignore the reports provided by Rune Investments, taking the view she had been advised ‘not to do anything as it had been like that for years’ and nothing had happened.

Post-cyclone Gabrielle, engineers suggested a rudimentary timber retaining wall installed by Ms Larsen and a friend had in fact accentuated the problem, creating further erosion by concentrating water runoff.

Confirming an earlier District Court ruling, Justice Kawharu ruled Ms Larsen liable in nuisance for failing to take reasonably prompt and effective steps to deal with the problem.

Driveway construction for Ms Larsen’s 303B created a known defect risking future damage to her neighbour’s property, she said.

The extent of damage wrought following cyclone Gabrielle might not have been anticipated, but the risk of it occurring was known.

Damages of $350,000 for Rune Investments was calculated as the cost of remediating its property.

To avoid further damage to Rune Investments’ property at 303A, Ms Larsen was ordered to install a properly drained retaining wall.

Larsen v. Runes Investments Pty Ltd – High Court (28.08.26)

26.244

24 August 2026

Loan: Hill v. Down

  

Russel Down twisted and turned in multiple failed attempts to avoid repaying the balance well overdue on a $60,000 loan received from his sister fifteen years ago.

The District Court dismissed his claim that the loan was made not to him personally, but to his Auckland used car dealership, wound up insolvent back in 2013.

He was ordered to honour a 2022 family agreement with payment from his share of their late father’s estate; another agreement he denied existed.

Evidence was given of Mr Russel borrowing $60,000 from his sister Christine Hill and her husband back in 2009, to purchase stock for his car dealership on Wairau Road in Auckland’s North Shore.   

The loan was unsecured.  No interest was agreed.

Partial repayments were made in dribs and drabs over the next four years, leaving $31,500 still unpaid in early 2013, several months before his car yard folded.

Arrangements were firmed up in early 2022 when Mr Down signed an acknowledgement that money was still owed, agreeing to assign to his sister the inheritance he expected from their late father’s estate; this to be in full and final payment.

It was only later in court that he admitted ever signing this agreement.

The court was told their father died in 2005 with each of his children to receive a one-eighth share of the family home in Levin, with sale postponed until his widow chose to live elsewhere.

In late 2023 she shifted out. The house was sold, with Mr Down in line to receive a $68,000 inheritance.

The house sold for a far greater sum than anyone anticipated at time of the 2022 family arrangement where Mr Down agreed to hand over all his expected inheritance in repayment of the $31,500 unpaid debt.

Sister Christine told the court it was understood when signing that her brother’s potential inheritance could come in at either more or less than what was owed; each side took the risk.

If it was less, she was going to take the loss, Christine said.

Later, Christine decided out of fairness to her brother that she would not claim his full $68,000 inheritance, instead taking $40,500: the unpaid debt still owed of $31,500 plus $9000 as interest.

Mr Down agreed to this compromise; making a ten dollar test payment into her nominated bank account, ostensibly a precursor to payment of the agreed $40,500.

The court was told Mr Down then kept his entire inheritance, refusing to pay his sister anything.

Judge Rowe ordered payment of the agreed $40,500; on equitable grounds of promissory estoppel.

Terms of the compromise were agreed.

Mr Down’s oral agreement was further evidenced by his conduct in making the ten dollar test payment.

Sister Christine took him at his word, deciding in response not take any action freezing payment he might otherwise receive from their late father’s estate.

This response was to her detriment; now unable to freeze Mr Down’s share as he had already received payment.

Ordered to pay the agreed $40,500, Mr Down cannot now go back on his word, Judge Rowe said.

Hill v. Down – District Court (24.08.26)

26.243

21 August 2026

Will: re Christian Paul Money

  

A text message sent from hospital by Christian Money eleven days before his death was accepted by the High Court as a valid will, leaving all his assets to his mother and his siblings.

Wills Act sets out strict formalities for a valid will: requiring the document to be in writing, signed, and acknowledged with the signatures of two witnesses.

Testamentary wishes falling short of these requirements can be validated as a will if expressing a deceased’s ‘testamentary intentions.’

The High Court heard Christian was admitted to hospital in October 2025, aged 49.

Three days later, he sent a long text to his brother Gabriel referring to his possible death, stating what should happen to his assets.

Gabriel saw his brother in hospital later that day, where Christian confirmed what he had texted, with one minor alteration.

He wanted all left to his mother Ruth and his siblings: Gabriel and Sarah.

Evidence was given of Christian having no other immediate blood relatives.

He owned his own home and lived alone.

There was no record of Christian being married, having lived in a de facto relationship, or having children.

With no evidence of any other person having a potential interest in the estate, Justice Tantrum ruled the text message and oral variation to be Christian Money’s final will.

re Christian Paul Money – High Court (21.08.26)

26.242

Sale of Land: van Duinen v. van Duinen

  

In a father/son dispute, the High Court ruled Mark van Duinen could not block his father Robert’s sale of a property near Ashburton because Mark’s supposed claim to a 25 per cent share of the property was an oral agreement only.

Oral agreements for sale of land are valid, but Property Law Act rules require written evidence of a contract to sell land if court enforcement is needed.

In the High Court, father Robert said there was never any agreement to sell a share of the Ashburton property to his son; at best it was an oral agreement for his son to build him a dwelling on the property in return for wages, free board and contributions towards living expenses, he said.

Mark told the High Court he moved from Blenheim to Ashburton in late 2023 in response to his father’s suggestion the Ashburton property could be improved prior to sale with construction of a new dwelling.

He claims there was an agreement he be paid wages and get free board plus further agreement he would get a 25 per cent share of the property on completion.

Mark went as far as fencing off what he considered would become his 25 per cent share of the property.

Plans for the build went through several iterations before father and son fell out, with Mark trespassed from the property, complaining he had not been paid agreed wages for work done.

When his father later sold the property, Mark lodged a caveat on the title, blocking final settlement to enforce his claimed 25 per cent ownership share.

Associate judge Lester ruled the caveat could not remain.

Any supposed agreement for Mark’s share of the land was oral only; not enforceable.

Evidence was given of a handwritten agreement, signed only by Mark, setting out when progress payments for his wages might be paid.  This written document made no mention of a 25 per cent share of the land supposedly promised him.

Mark needs to come back to court with further evidence if seeking to rely instead on the equitable doctrine of part performance, Judge Lester said.

Oral contracts for sale of land are enforceable where one party has already carried out his part of the bargain.

First: Mark must prove there was in fact an oral agreement for transfer to him of a 25 per cent share of the land, Judge Lester said.

Second: it must be proved Mark completed his part of the work as promised, such that it is inequitable for this oral agreement not to be enforced.

van Duinen v. van Duinen – High Court (21.08.26)

26.241

20 August 2026

Freezing Order: Verma v. Ali

  

Former employees of Ameer Ali’s Christchurch business Fiji Food Distributors are owed wage arrears of $450,000; Fiji Food now wound up insolvent with its only asset supposedly being a bank account containing six dollars.  The High Court refused to partially lift current freezing orders over assets allegedly linked to Fiji Food director Ameer Ali.

Fiji Food Distributors formerly traded as Krazy Price Mart.   

In 2025, Employment Relations Authority held both Fiji Food Distributors Ltd and Mr Ali liable to pay damages to four former employees. 

They remain unpaid.

The liquidator’s first report for Fiji Food after its liquidation in 2026 records the company’s only asset as a six dollar bank balance.

This report also states there are believed to be Employment Relations Authority awards of some $600,000 owed by the company, currently unpaid.

The High Court was told of a series of property transfers from Mr Ali to his son Azmir Ali at a time when the ultimately successful employee claims were yet to be decided by the Authority.  Assets transferred out of Mr Ali’s name were his family home at Lexington Place in Christchurch, and his shareholdings in two family companies.

In June 2026, High Court freezing orders were placed over these assets.

Two months later, Mr Ali’s brother Shabbir Ali was in the High Court asking that the freezing order be lifted from a company called Alis Family Investment Ltd.

Shabbir Ali told the court that his brother Ameer never had any ownership interest in the company.  Ameer was made a shareholder in error; the shares should have been registered years ago in name of Ameer’s son Azmir and that the subsequent transfer of these shares out of Ameer Ali’s name into name of his son Azmir was simply correcting this error, he said.

The current freezing order was blocking development plans proposed for Alis Family Investment, he said.  

Justice Osborne refused to lift the freezing order to the extent it affected Alis Family Investments.

The ‘big picture’ did not warrant any partial release, he said.

Ameer Ali and his extended family, including his son Azmir and brother Shabbir, have close family and business connections with companies being run as family businesses, he said.

Here, Ameer who was facing significant financial peril as an Employment Relations Authority hearing approached, achieved in a matter of months a situation whereby, on the face of it, he became assetless, Justice Osborne said.

Questions were raised about how the Lexington Place family home was transferred to son Azmir at no apparent cost with indications that further borrowing against Lexington Place was then put into Alis Family Investments prior to the court application to have Alis Family Investment assets released from the High Court freeze.

The court was told Ameer Ali continues to live at Lexington Place.

Son Azmir is employed by the Air Force, living in Auckland.

The asset freeze remains, Justice Osborne ruled.  There is a risk of assets being dissipated prior to a full court hearing, he said.

Yet to be heard is a full Property Law Act court hearing on whether assets currently frozen should be transferred back into the name of Ameer Ali on grounds they were transfers intended to defeat creditors’ claims.

Verma v. Ali – High Court (20.08.26)

26.240

Lease: Westhaven Investments v. Viaduct Harbour

  

Economic logic bowed to legal rules in an unsuccessful challenge by Carey family’s Westhaven Investments to a ground lease rent review for their site in downtown Auckland’s Wynyard Quarter, with $2.6 million in dispute for a further eleven year’s rent.   

Westhaven claimed new rents should be discounted to reflect the fact that when current ground leases expire in 2054 all improvements on the land pass to the lessor: Viaduct Harbour Holdings Ltd.

Investors behind Viaduct Harbour Holdings acquired large swathes of prime commercial land bordering Auckland harbour in the 1990s, from the then Auckland Harbour Board.

The area has been rejuvenated, with mixed-use commercial, residential and hospitality sectors.

Land is leased out on long-term leases, ensuring developers have sufficient time to recover a return on their capital invested as sites are redeveloped.  

Westhaven Investments building on Westhaven Drive sits on a 72 year ground lease with just over thirty years to run.  An eleven-year rent renewal came due in 2022.

Rent renewals for its lease are assessed on unimproved value of the land; the leased land is assumed to be a vacant lot.

For terminating ground leases where there is no contractual right to compensation for improvements made to the land, the day of reckoning comes at conclusion of the lease.  The lessor collects what has been described as a windfall gain: buildings constructed on the land by lessees during term of the lease.

For lessee sales during term of the lease, value of a lessee’s right of occupation steadily reduces, eventually reducing to zero.

At an arbitration to settle the 2022 rent renewal, Westhaven Investments said new rents should be reduced to reflect what a prudent lessee would pay now to take over the lease, recognising the fateful day in 2054 when the lease terminates.

Westhaven offered $340,000 annual rent for the next eleven-year period; Viaduct Holdings wanted $540,000.

Arbitrators agreed with Viaduct, stating the $540,000 calculation was consistent with both terms of the lease and the intended purpose of the rent review.

Both sides previously agreed their arbitration would be ‘final and binding.’

Westhaven appealed to the High Court, claiming arbitrators made an ‘error of law.’

Ruling that the arbitrators were correct, Justice Becroft accepted that the wording and commercial setting of the lease counted against any discount.

Viaduct argued that if rent were to be discounted at the ‘back end’ because of the shortening lease term, it should logically have been higher at the ‘front end.’

Lessees should not get the benefit of a back-end reduction without earlier paying a higher amount at the front end, it said.

Westhaven Investments Ltd v. Viaduct Harbour Holdings Ltd – High Court (20.08.26)

26.239

19 August 2026

Rent-to-Buy: Wells v. Faasavalu

  

Faced with eviction from their Otara home, South Auckland couple Vainiua Faasavalu and Fia Tuiaana had the court reopen earlier litigation, belatedly arguing a thirty year rent to buy agreement for their home is an oppressive credit contract.

As a general rule, contracts for purchase of land are not covered by consumer credit protection legislation.  They are not credit contracts.  They are purchase of an asset, typically with agreement that payment in full settlement is delayed by a few weeks.

Longer delays before full payment, with a requirement to pay interest in the interim, sees rent-to-buy deals for land potentially treated as consumer credit contracts.

The High Court was told the couple signed up in March 2005 to buy their Clayton Avenue property with weekly instalments towards the purchase price plus interest spread over three decades.

The vendor was a company associated with Mr Faasavalu’s then employer.

Members of the Wells family, shareholders of this company, later took over the thirty year contract to sell.

They sued to recover possession of the land in late 2025 after Mr Faasavalu and Ms Tuiaana fell behind on weekly payments.

The Wells claim $963,500 is owed: $213,500 unpaid balance of the purchase price and $750,000 for outstanding and ongoing interest, plus charges.

The two ignored court papers served on them, resulting in an unopposed Property Law Act order requiring them to leave Clayton Avenue.

They later got High Court approval to reopen their case, saying they did not understand the significance of court documents served on them earlier.

Justice Gault said they have an arguable case that the rent-to-buy contract is a consumer credit contract that should be reviewed.  

They allege the contract is oppressive in that Mr Faasavalu was dissuaded from getting independent advice when signing up and that it was obvious he would struggle to pay weekly instalments of $460 on a then take-home pay of $600.   

While arrears still remain unpaid, the court was told the two are currently meeting a requirement they pay $650 weekly.

Whether their rent-to-buy contract should be amended as an oppressive credit contract is yet to be decided.

The disputed contract was signed in early 2005.  Rules in the subsequently repealed Credit Contracts Act still apply.

Current rules in the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act came into effect several weeks after their rent-to-buy agreement was signed. 

Wells v. Faasavalu – High Court (19.08.26)

26.238

Family Trust: Norton v. Kemp-Towns

  

Registered on title to her mother’s Auckland property as trustee of her mother’s family trust gave daughter Dee Kemp-Towns no rights of personal occupation after her mother shifted to care in a retirement village, with Ms Kemp-Towns also disputing circumstances of her removal as trustee.

Ms Kemp-Towers moved into her mother’s Puriri Avenue Greenlane home in July 2024, assisting after her near ninety year old widowed mother was injured in a fall.  

Some nine months later, her mother established a family trust with Puriri Avenue later transferred to this trust.

Ms Kemp-Towers came to be registered on title to Puriri Avenue as one of two founding trustees; the other being her mother’s lawyer, Susan Norton.

The High Court was told Ms Norton arranged to have Ms Kemp-Towers replaced as joint trustee after concerns about her operation of her mother’s bank account, with allegations of improper withdrawals of some $37,000.  Police became involved.

Ms Kemp-Towers remained at Puriri Avenue, refusing to leave, after her mother’s September 2025 shift to a retirement village.

Sale of Puriri Avenue is necessary to fund village care expenses.

The High Court dismissed Ms Kemp-Towers claim that the fact her name was listed on title to Puriri Avenue gave her the right to live there.

Legal formalities to have her replaced as one of the named trustees on the title were yet to be finalised.

Merely holding title to an asset as trustee gives no personal ownership rights, Associate Judge Wild ruled.

Trustees must comply with terms of any trust.

While she is named as a beneficiary, wording of her mother’s trust gives Ms Kemp-Towns no personal occupation rights.

She was given two weeks to leave.

Complaints by Ms Kemp-Towers about circumstances of her removal as a trustee were a separate legal issue, irrelevant to her unfounded claim to an occupation right, Judge Wild ruled.

Norton v. Kemp-Towns – High Court (19.08.26)

26.237