22 September 2022

Leasehold: KOL Holdings v. Xu

Owners of twenty-one leasehold apartments on Auckland’s Remuera Road have had their leases cancelled following a rent strike when annual rents more than doubled in 2021 on a seven-year rent review.

The High Court was told owners had abandoned their leased properties with power subsequently cut off for unpaid arrears. Freehold title to the apartments at 267 Remuera Road is held by property company KOL Holdings Ltd with Anthony David Frith and Anna Kristina Frith named as both directors and shareholders.

Lease terms permit KOL to review rent every seven years. The 2021 review saw annual rent for the block of predominately small studio apartments rise from $250,000 to $645,000 with GST to be added.  Leasehold owners walked away.  Legal action was taken against eight owners who had not done a deal for surrender of their lease. The High Court ruled these eight were jointly and severally liable for rent arrears of some $1.03 million and rates arrears of just over $115,000. Joint and several liability leaves each of the eight leaseholders liable to contribute equally to the amount due, but if one does not pay then the other leaseholders have to make good the difference. At a minimum, each is liable to pay more than $140,000 with no compensation for loss of their leasehold interest. 

At KOL Holdings’ request, the High Court cancelled all twenty-one apartment leases giving KOL complete control of the site. A hotel advertising itself as the Devereux Boutique Hotel sits to the rear of the property, partially obscured by the studio apartments.

KOL Holdings Ltd v. Xu – High Court (22.09.22)

22.169