Left stranded as part-owner of a Bay of Plenty property with no ability to remove a tenant enjoying two decades of below market rent, or even being able to sell, because fellow co-owners refused to engage, caused the High Court to order a forced sale with net proceeds divided fifty/fifty.
Moewai Roberts became owner of a half share in the 92 hectare rural property in 2008 after her husband’s death. Owner of the other half share died the following year, with ownership of that half share held since 2009 by Maramoa Mauga and Michael Wilson as estate executors.
The High Court was told these two executors have ignored existence of this estate asset.
The property at Waimana, inland between Whakatane and Opotiki, was leased prior to Ms Robert’s inheritance to a company called L.A. Brown & Sons Ltd, described on the Companies Office register as a dairy and cattle farm.
Evidence was given of Brown & Sons original lease expiring in 2007 with the company continuing in occupation over the next twenty years without a renewed lease, paying the original rental of some $7000 per year.
Current market rentals for a property of this size vary between $36,000 and $48,000, the court was told.
Rentals have been paid to Ms Roberts. The amount now barely covers likely outgoings for rates and insurance.
Ms Roberts said she has been unable to renegotiate the rent because the co-owners will not co-operate; necessary to sign off on a new lease. The two estate executors are believed to be living in Australia.
Now in her eighties, Ms Roberts wants to sell. The property has a current market value of between $1.7 million and $1.9 million.
Justice Harvey ordered a Property Law Act sale, with Ms Roberts alone authorised to end Brown & Sons occupation and to negotiate a sale price with intending purchasers.
Fifty per cent of net proceeds is to be held in trust for beneficiaries of the inactive estate.
Separately, Ms Roberts asked that damages be deducted from the estate’s other half share as compensation for lost rent; her half share of lost rent likely to exceed $100,000.
The executors’ lack of engagement as co-owners has prevented any rent increase for over two decades, she complained.
A separate hearing is needed to determine liability for rent, Justice Harvey ruled.
Executors have the right to challenge this separate claim.
Substituted notice of the earlier Property Law Act sale application was served on the two executors by email.
They did not respond.
Roberts v. Mauga – High Court (4.09.26)
26.251