04 September 2026

Intestacy: Rimmer v. Wilton

  

Property relationship agreements specifying what happens to assets on death override any statutory right to inherit on an intestacy the Supreme Court ruled in a case so vexing to the legal profession that the court took an unusual step of hearing submissions from the Law Society.

David Rimmer died in 2016, having no will; leaving assets to be divided between near relatives by a statutory formula set out in the Administration Act.

Surviving de facto partner Carolyn Wilton claimed she was entitled both to a share of property as set out fourteen years previously in their Property (Relationships) Act ‘contracting out’ agreement and also as a surviving spouse to benefit from her Administration Act statutory rights to inherit on an intestacy.

You cannot contract out of Administration Act rules, she said.

The High Court agreed.

Practical problems for lawyers surfaced immediately.

Negotiations and concessions needed from all sides when finalising a ‘contracting out’ agreement were undone should one spouse die intestate without a will, or have prior wills invalidated for any reason.

Whatever the balance between spouses intended when signing a contracting out agreement could in future be seriously undermined.

The Supreme Court was told the major asset in David Rimmer’s estate was a lifestyle block on Moumoukai Road at Hunua in South Auckland, owned jointly by Mr Rimmer and Ms Wilton.

They held title as tenants in common, meaning Ms Wilton did not take his half share by survivorship on death.  Mr Rimmer’s half share remains an asset in his estate on death.

As surviving spouse on an intestacy, Ms Wilton was entitled to one-third of Mr Rimmer’s half share, the High Court ruled.

Mr Rimmer’s two adult children from an earlier relationship also inherit under Administration Act rules.

The Supreme Court ruled that Ms Wilton could not claim an Administration Act inheritance.

Wording of her earlier Property (Relationships) Act contracting out agreement by implication had the effect of her disclaiming any Administration Act inheritance.

Their agreement listed Moumoukai Road as relationship property, with each entitled to a share based on the capital contribution each made to the asset.

The court was told this formula entitles Ms Wilton to a 56.45 per cent interest in Moumoukai Road, rather than the fifty per cent interest recorded on the title.   

Their agreement further stated that the survivor of the two had a right of lifetime occupancy, ending on death of the survivor.

This limited Ms Wilton’s entitlement to her late spouse’s half share to a life interest only,

operating as a pre-existing disclaimer to any further Administration Act entitlement, the Supreme Court ruled.

The court was told Moumoukai Road was sold in 2021 for $1.2 million, with the estate’s half share currently held in trust pending a final court ruling.

Rimmer v. Wilton – Supreme Court (4.09.26)

26.252