27 November 2017

Asset Forfeiture: Commissioner of Police v. Drake & Stewart

Leticia Drake and Gavin Stewart had their Christchurch home and earthquake insurance payouts seized as proceeds of crime having been funded with money from benefit fraud.   
Drake, currently serving two years nine months jail for benefit fraud, left fellow staff at Countdown so annoyed with her tales of living it up on welfare whilst working that they dobbed her in. The High Court was told she received more than $250,000 over a fifteen year period in what was described as a highly premeditated and cynical benefit fraud.  Recoveries under the Criminal Proceeds (Recovery) Act can go back only seven years.  Fraudulently claimed welfare benefits and Working for Family tax credits totalled $136,500 for the seven year period.
The family home in Emmett Street, Shirley, was purchased from Housing NZ in March 2010.  It was then substantially upgraded and refurbished.  Justice Dunningham ruled any property improved by the proceeds of crime is ‘tainted’ and can be confiscated.  Benefits were paid into Drake’s bank account and this money used not only for household expenses but also for mortgage payments, payment of insurance premiums and to renovate their home.  The Emmett Street property was confiscated, together with earthquake insurance payouts totalling $23,100 and funds held in a bank account.
Mr Stewart benefitted from the fraud, Justice Dunningham said.  His own funds were freed up by having fraudulent benefit payments help fund their purchase and renovations.  Justice Dunningham dismissed as not credible Mr Stewart’s claim to be unaware of Drake’s long running benefit fraud over the time he was her de facto partner.  Mr Stewart was described as a self-employed electrician.  There was evidence of tax evasion with Mr Stewart doing cash jobs on the side and not declaring income.          
Commissioner of Police v. Drake & Stewart – High Court (27.11.17)

18.012